Win the Week: Honestly
An essay by Tim Gerhan

Miss a day, fake a day, stop using.

Why I built Win the Week.

It was 9:30pm and I just couldn’t get myself to get changed to workout. I didn’t want my fitness streak to end, so I opened my habit tracker, clicked complete, and quickly put it away. I didn’t feel great about it. The next night, I hadn’t gotten my 30 minutes of exercise in again. This night was much easier. I just clicked complete and told myself I would definitely do it tomorrow. I didn’t.

I didn’t open the app again for a month. When I felt the itch to start a new habit, I looked on my phone and saw that in the past year I’d downloaded five habit tracker apps. Each one started with promise. Better charts, better notifications, better widgets. But in the end I fell into the same pattern. Miss a day, fake a day, stop using. The dopamine of completing a habit only lasted as long as the streak. The moment it broke, the whole thing fell apart. All of them were dressed up in different colors and graphics, but underneath they were the same app.

I sat with it for a while. Did I even care about the habits I was tracking? I drank all my water for 10 days in a row. Was that really making me a better person? The apps could tell me I was winning. They couldn’t tell me whether any of it mattered.

I wanted simplicity, with a little more insight. So I opened Apple Notes and wrote at the top: “Do I feel better now than when I woke up?” That was it. Each night I’d put the date, write yes or no, and a sentence about why. Sixty seconds. After a few weeks I had a long list of yes and no days, and a bunch of small notes underneath.

It worked, but I wanted more. More simplicity, more I could relate to. Then I remembered a coach I’d heard on TV talking about how you just have to win the day. That was it. I changed the question to “Did I win today?” Underneath, I’d write a sentence about the day. Win or loss.

After a while I had long notes of wins and losses but no real way to read them. Was I actually winning, overall? Were there days that kept showing up as losses? The Apple Note couldn’t tell me. I’d been dabbling in small apps for my family. Earlier that year I’d built one for my son to track his bowling scores over the season, so I decided to build one for myself. Simple, useful, honest.

In Win the Week, you write one honest question a week. Something like “Did I make myself present with my family?” Every night you answer it Win or Loss and write a sentence about what actually happened. The scorecard goes seven games like a series. Four wins takes it. Four losses takes it. Either way you settle the week and start the next one fresh.

This is where I am now. Each week giving myself one question I can focus on every day. Truthfully asking myself, did I win or did I lose? No middle ground. Making sure I put down a reason. Still sixty seconds. If I miss a day, the day just stays empty. The week keeps going. It is the act of logging over time, and finding out whether you are actually changing.

A week where you honestly lose 3–4 is always better than a fake 5–2 win.


The fake 5–2 looks better. On paper, it’s a winning week. If you screenshot it and show it to someone, they’d believe it. But the fake 5–2 doesn’t tell you anything about yourself. You can’t learn from it. It’s not a record of a week, it’s a costume of one.

The honest 3–4 is a record. Four losses with a real sentence under each is four pieces of information you didn’t have seven days ago. Maybe two of them had the same reason. Maybe you read them at the end of the week and notice something you couldn’t see in the moment. The 3–4 can teach you something that the 5–2 can’t.

A single honest week teaches you about that week. Twenty honest weeks teach you about yourself. You notice you keep losing on Wednesdays. The same word keeps appearing in the sentences underneath. Tired. Rushed. Phone. The pattern doesn’t reveal itself in a week. It reveals itself across them.

A best-of-seven series exists because nobody wins them all. The NBA Finals are best-of-seven. The Stanley Cup Final is best-of-seven. The World Series is best-of-seven. The format exists because over seven games, the better team usually wins, but not always, and rarely cleanly. The losing team almost always wins at least one. That’s not a flaw in the format. That’s the whole point of the format.

A great baseball team in a championship season still loses about 40% of their games. Winning 60% of the time makes you a contender. Winning 70% makes you one of the best teams of the decade.

So why would a normal week of your life look any different? Why would you expect to win 7–0 at being present with your family, or 7–0 at listening more than you talked, or 7–0 at anything that’s actually hard?

You wouldn’t. Nobody would. And yet almost every habit tracker on the App Store is built around the idea that a perfect streak is the goal and a broken streak is the failure. That isn’t how anything else in life is scored. We don’t say a team had a bad season because they lost a game in October.

Four wins takes the week. Four losses takes the week. Either way, it’s information. Either way, you actually know what happened.


I should be honest about one more thing.

This isn’t an argument for an app. You could do this with a notebook. You could do this with the Apple Note I started with. The four-of-seven structure isn’t anything new, it’s just borrowed from sports. The act of writing a true sentence about your day takes sixty seconds and doesn’t require software.

I built Win the Week because I wanted something that made the practice consistent, that I could read back over time, that didn’t try to talk me into faking the score. But the practice is the thing, not the app. If you read this and start writing one honest sentence a night in a notebook, that’s the same outcome.

Miss a day, fake a day, stop using is what the old apps trained me to do. I wanted something that would let me lose honestly instead. That’s all.

The week doesn’t have to be won. It just has to be known.